Drink-in the immediate aftermath of Barnabas Seabeard’s sinister plot. “Here’s to the prosperity of all pirates!” he exclaimed. But while he and his crew enjoyed some ceremonial rum, the unwitting others chugged something with a little more kick. As is “kick the brine bucket.” For the wily Cap poisoned ‘em all, clearing the path to grab the spoils from their ships. The greatest coup in seafaring history was underway, but it was anything but smooth sailing…

See what happens next: Shiver Me Timbers