Captain Barnabas Seabeard’s nefarious plan to amass the greatest treasure in history begins here. Feast your eyes on the actual Jolly Rogers of some of the most notorious pirates in history. From Blackbeard to Bartholomew “Black Bart” Roberts and more seafaring scallywags, it’s a hall of infamy.

Seabeard’s scheme? Amidst tense times at sea, he called a meeting of all captains and their crews to Tortuga Island. To make peace. To sort out whose waters be whose. For the betterment of all pirates. Or so he would have them believe. Little did they know this wasn’t a destination – it was a dead end…

See what happens next: And a Bottle ‘o Rum